New Jersey isn’t just famous for its boardwalks and diners—it’s also home to some of the best pizza you’ll ever eat. Whether you prefer thin crust, thick crust, or something in between, this guide has you covered. These 10 pizza spots each boast a 4.0+ rating on Google, ensuring you’ll get nothing but the best slices.
1. Rosie’s Pizza
Located in Point Pleasant Rosie’s is known for its charred, bubbly crust and fresh ingredients. Their Margherita pizza is a standout, and the cozy atmosphere makes it perfect for families and casual outings.
Must-Try: Margherita Pizza
2. Angeloni’s
A hidden gem in Caldwell, Angeloni’s is a staple for locals who rave about their thin-crust pies. Their consistency and perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio make it a must-visit for pizza purists. Pro Tip: Get the Thinny Thin with Garlic.
Must-Try: Plain Cheese Pie
3. Star Tavern
Head over to West Orange to experience the thin-crust, tavern-style pizza Star Tavern is famous for. The crispy crust and generous toppings make it a longtime favorite among pizza lovers.
Must-Try: Pepperoni Pizza
4. De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies
Located in Robbinsville, this iconic pizzeria has been dishing out incredible tomato pies for generations. Their signature crisp crust and perfectly balanced tomato sauce keep customers coming back year after year.
Must-Try: Plain Tomato Pie
5. Razza
Based in Jersey City, Razza has earned national acclaim for its artisanal, wood-fired pizza. Each ingredient—from the homemade mozzarella to the heirloom wheat crust—is thoughtfully sourced for maximum flavor.
Must-Try: Jersey Margherita
6. Brooklyn Square Pizza
Stop by Jackson to try Brooklyn Square’s renowned upside-down Sicilian pizza. The cheese goes under the sauce, leaving the crust crispy while the rich tomato flavor shines through.
Must-Try: Upside-Down Sicilian
7. Kinchley’s Tavern
Ridgewood locals swear by Kinchley’s Tavern, a rustic spot dishing out ultra-thin-crust pies. Their inventive topping combinations and casual vibe make it a hit for group outings.
Must-Try: Meat Lover’s Pizza
8. Pete & Elda’s / Carmen’s Pizzeria
Located in Neptune City, Pete & Elda’s is the go-to for crispy, thin-crust pies with a slight crunch. They even have a challenge—finish an XXL pizza yourself and earn a T-shirt!
Must-Try: XXL Thin-Crust Pie
9. Brick Oven Restaurant
Located in Ridgewood, Brick Oven specializes in authentic Neapolitan-style pizza cooked in—you guessed it—a giant brick oven. Each bite has a delicate balance of softness and charred crispness.
Must-Try: Quattro Stagioni (Four Seasons Pizza)
10. Tony D’s
This family-owned spot in Caldwell is all about quality. Tony D’s serves classic New York-style pizza with a crust that’s crisp yet chewy, and their signature sauce is perfectly savory.
Must-Try: Grandma’s Pie
Explore these top-rated pizza spots and find your personal favorite. After all, no matter how you like your pie, New Jersey has the perfect slice waiting for you. Who’s hungry? 🍕