Looking for one of the top 10 sandwiches in New Jersey? Whether you’re cruising through North Jersey, chilling near NYC, or venturing close to Pennsylvania, this list is packed with flavor bombs. From classic Italian subs to chicken cutlets that hit the spot, these sandwich spots deliver every. single. time.
1. Millburn Deli – Millburn, NJ
Known for their signature sloppy joes (not the messy kind), Millburn Deli is a local icon. Fresh ingredients, perfectly stacked layers, and that irresistible deli vibe—just trust us on this one.
What to order: The Godfadda or the Gobbler
2. Joe Leone’s Italian Specialties – Point Pleasant Beach, NJ
A beach trip essential. Joe Leone’s is bringing legit Italian flavors with their deli sandwiches. Huge portions, fresh mozzarella, and an unrelenting commitment to greatness.
What to order: Italian Combo or Chicken Parm Sub
3. Watchung Deli – Watchung, NJ
A hidden gem with a cult following! Watchung Deli serves hefty sandwiches with fresh cuts and creative combos. This spot is perfect for a post-adventure (/munchies) meal.
What to order: The Fat Cat or the Twisted Turkey
4. Livingston Bagel – Livingston, NJ
Okay, bagels count, right? This spot does bagel sandwiches right—whether it’s breakfast or lunch, their combos are always fire. Plus, they don’t mess around with their portions.
What to order: Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on Everything Bagel
5. Bloom Chicken – Bloomfield, NJ
Calling all chicken sandwich fans—Bloom Chicken is a true standout. Crispy, juicy, and ridiculously flavorful, their sandwiches redefine comfort food.
What to order: Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
6. Fiore’s Deli – Hoboken, NJ
Hoboken’s pride and joy. If “mozz” isn’t in your vocabulary yet, Fiore’s will change that. Known for their legendary roast beef sandwich with fresh mozzarella.
What to order: Roast Beef and Mozzarella Hero
7. Chicken Cutler Sandwich Spot (Caldwell) – Caldwell, NJ
This unnamed haven for chicken cutlets in Caldwell is kind of a word-of-mouth treasure. Perfectly breaded cutlets with all the fixings.
What to order: Chicken Cutlet with Fresh Mutz and Vodka Sauce
8. Hanover Deli – East Hanover, NJ
Straight-up classic deli vibes with a New Jersey twist. Their sandwiches cater to every craving and are jam-packed with flavor and heft.
What to order: Pastrami Reuben or Turkey Club
9. Hoagie Haven – Princeton, NJ
A Princeton legend. Hoagie Haven’s subs are enormous, stuffed to the brim, and packed with bold flavors. It’s definitely worth the drive from wherever you are.
What to order: The Sanchez or the Jersey Torch
10. Vito’s Deli – Hoboken, NJ
Another Hoboken favorite—because why not? Vito’s combines fresh, high-quality ingredients with loads of Italian-American charm.
What to order: The Sinatra Special
Bonus Tip
For maximum sandwich enjoyment, bring your crew, find a chill spot, and prepare to be blissed out. Whether you’re a New Jersey local or just visiting, these spots guarantee sandwiches you’ll be dreaming about.
Tag your sandwich crew and drop your fave below! 🥪✨
